The writer does not say if the lens can be manually focused or if the
problem occurs in bright sunlight. If it can be manually focused the problem
is likely due to not enough light reaching the autofocus sensor because of
the maximum aperture being too small.
I had two Nikon 55-200s that could not find focus regardless of focal length
or lighting conditions, hence all Nikon lenses are sh*t? Well that
particular one is and one of the worst lenses I have ever seen regardless of
manufacturer.
The 28-200/300 category, as a whole, regardless of manufacturer (including
Nikon) are not very good designs anyway.
The digital only 18-200s are much better performers as a whole, including
the insanely overpriced Nikon 18-200 (call me crazy, I own one) but should
not be confused with high grade optics.
>> Stay informed about: Sigma lens